Although this scenario is unlikely, and is more likely to take place through a proxy war, should russia invade turkey, who would win. European union eu vs russia 2017 who would win army military comparison. Who would win if russia, china, and america went to war. The other alternative is for the usa to use other countries such as ukraine to wage a war on their behalf which would be more acceptable to the us public. Who would win the united kingdom or france an ageold rivalry that stems far back into history. In a scenario where those countries fought and there were no nukes, the united states and its allies would have a qualitative advantage in armaments and a huge advantage on the seas, but the vastness of the territory a. On the western side, once the cold war had broken out, there was a much more positive engagement with the cold war, whereas on the soviet side there was a reluctance to become involved.
May 18, 2010 collectorbob, the uk has been an independent nuclear state since 1952, get back in your box. Aug 10, 2014 staunton, august 8 no state or regime goes to war firmly convinced that it will lose it, andrey piontkovsky says, and vladimir putin is no exception. Germany vs poland who would win military comparison. So the war devastated large areas of the russian countryside and its populace. Dont worry, the us would win a nuclear war with russia. The recent wars in lebanon, kosovo, afghanistan and iraq have clearly shown that welladapted tactics mostly deny the us.
Russia spends less on defence than the uk but, given that a lot of our budget is taken up on developing new nuclear weapons, we could lose out to a russian mass attack. List of books and articles about russian foreign policy. All it takes to nullify these advantages is an enemy who is aware of them and who refuses to fight what i call the american type of war on this concept, see here. Who would win a war between these countries and why. European union vs the united states eu vs usa 2017 who. The voice of russia is discussing it with paul craig roberts, former assistant secretary of the us treasury, currently the chairman of the institute for political economy. So, russia can do it, but i cant really think of a scenario in which theyd bother. S vs russia, in all out war in the pacific its just the two superpowers. At least they are for most of us who would rather read a book than watch sports or reality shows on the idiot box. Nations nucleararmed russia and china will side with in us v iran war revealed an iran expert has revealed who nuclear missilecapable superpowers russia and china would side with if. How true is the spreading belief that president obama has ruined us foreign policy, and how does it actually work. I mean, america spends more on weapons than the whole world combined, yet russia is very powerfuli think.
But as a russian i would say most certainly usa will not win the conventional war on russia s soil. Russia is developing only one stealth fighter but it has capabilities that some put on par with the f22. The bomb didnt beat japan stalin did foreign policy. If it comes to war with russia, does ukraine stand a chance. If america and russia went to war who would likely win. But rovner points out the dilemma at the heart of u. It might be appropriate to momentarily shift our focus away from the asymmetric threats of the taliban and isis and look at the world of. It has come to relevance since russia accused turkey of assisting isis, followed by turkey shooting down a russian jet. The pentagon is planning for war with china and russia can it handle both.
The common conclusion to these pieces is that usanato would lose a conventional war with russia and everybody would lose a nuclear war. These two have been vying for supremacy for millennia so it. The united states could lose in a war against either china or russia, defence officials have warned. Defence experts give verdict on their arsenals senior us defence experts have warned that relations between moscow and. They were enemies in the crimean war of the 1850s, and rivals in the great game for control of central asia in the latter half of the.
An raf officer, sir michael graydon, recently opined that britains firstclass air force would be swamped by the sheer number of russian planes if it. America is the most powerful nation, but the third largest country. Why did the russian leadership initiate military action against chechnya in december 1994 but against no other constituent part of the federation. Check out the infographics shows delightfully frightening breakdown of who would win if russia. Mar 21, 2014 no one is expecting war between russia and ukraine. The stereotype that the us arsenal is more survivable or better is also false. Could the united states defeat russia in all out war in. Its one of his favorites, with great illustrations and fun facts about each. Aaron mehta january 30, 2018 on display during a peoples liberation army air.
Chilling world war iii wargames show us forces crushed. European union vs the united states eu vs usa 2017 who would win. This nonfiction series builds background knowledge and research skills. For whatever reason in this hypothetical, australias allies have declined to be involved and are just watching. A world war i memoir by this exceptional german officer, who served almost exclusively on the russian front during ww 1. In 2017, who has a stronger military, the european union eu or the united states usa. The f22 would likely get a jump on the russians in a war, but would be in serious trouble if it was spotted first. Current tensions between russia and nato are leading many to carefully assess this question and.
However, as a predictor of what the near future might look like and how nato and the individual countries within need to prepare themselves general shirreff hits the bulls eye and hits it hard. There is an enormous sense of alarm, says mikhail gorbachev in rare media intervention. Defence experts give verdict on their arsenals senior us defence experts have warned that relations between moscow and washington have reached a low not. He serves as a senior lecturer at the patterson school of diplomacy and international commerce at the university of. Sep 26, 2017 russia is also reportedly developing a socalled terminator 3 tank support fighting vehicleduring the cold war, the russian defense budget amounted to nearly half of the countrys overall expenditures. Even if russia fights alone, it can kill over 100 million in a very short time frame, the most powerful nukes, the most nukes, the most tanks, and the most accurate missle in the world look at the guniess book of records the most accirate missles in the world. If russia started world war iii, heres how it would go down. Along russia s southern borders, postindependence instability offered opportunities to retain a military presence in the name of peacekeeping among warring factions or nations. And top military and intelligence leaders presented an assessment of those plans.
Current tensions between russia and nato are leading many to carefully assess this question and examine the current state of weaponry and technological. The pentagon is planning for war with china and russia. Putin believes he can win a war with nato, piontkovsky says. Goodbye war on terror, hello china and russia foreign policy. Something about the war that we are pondering should be made clear at the outset. But if its a sea war, then uk is ready as ever to give it a blast. These two have been vying for supremacy for millennia so it only seems fair to allow them to face. Closely modelled on his nato experience of war gaming future conflicts, 2017 war with russia is a chilling account of where we are heading if we fail to recognise the threat posed by the russian president. But you cant analyze japans decision to surrender objectively in the.
Russia and britain became allies against napoleon in the early19th century. If it tries to win quickly, it might trigger nuclear war. Usa does nto have many partners like the uk does, it has alot of war heads but if you take that out its a differant story. I know that our american friends like to think that their army the best.
Oct 11, 2016 would russia or the us win a world war. Google trends recorded iran as the most searched term in the uk. But if it comes to that, ukraine is hardly a match for russia on most counts. Which country has the better military, in terms of technology, motivation, and strategy. Jan 06, 2012 on june 22, 1941, adolf hitler invaded the soviet union.
It has an overwhelming advantage in naval power and industrial production. Also known as the pak fa, its less stealthy than the raptor but more maneuverable. Jun 02, 2016 russia is accused of coordinating a hybrid war in ukraine and in syria putin has used military force outside the borders of the former soviet union for the first time since the end of the. Now a days socialism is improved to give freedom for religionsfaiths found in our world. Soviet russia in the second world war bellamy, chris on. Us and russia closer to open conflict than any time since. However, it is most likely neither would surrender unless the war dragged on for decades and was all out war.
In case the united states and russia engage in nuclear confrontation, the us will be completely wiped off the face of the earth, editor of europesolidaire jeanpaul baquiast wrote russia and china stand better chances in a possible nuclear war against the us, which would mean complete destruction of the united states territory, the french journalist said. Russia will not allow this and as such the usa will need ground troops in full scale battle. Thus, because of that thread being 11 pages long, i feel a new thread must be developed with the presupposition that nuclear war can be won, and it would be won by russia. The best way to get good at anything is too actually go out and do it and do it a lot. The stereotype that no one can win a nuclear war is false. After the political fallout from the bali 9 etc, tensions became worse between the two countries and war began. The cold war wasnt us vs russia, it was west vs east nato vs warsaw. Who would win in a hypothetical war between russia and the. Russia vs the united states who would win military comparison. Remember in the cold war russia was weakend because of the law of socialism. May 20, 2016 the evil gloating trope is much in evidence in general sir richard shirreffs 2017. The last time china fought a major war was the year i was born.
Forget britains nuclear deterrent heres what russia is really. Collectorbob, the uk has been an independent nuclear state since 1952, get back in your box. Goodbye war on terror, hello china and russia five reads. To put russia s wwii role into a proper perspective, the book also covers approximately a decade of soviet history before and after the war, making the period covered roughly the years of stalins rule. For more than two centuries, and despite being situated in different hemispheres, the u. Us and russia closer to open conflict than any time since cold war. Russia s war by richard overy is a history of russia s role in wwii. Could the united states defeat russia in all out war in the.
Us war against russia is already underway pcr interviewed. Nov 21, 2014 if the world really is on the brink of world war 3, which country would come out on top. The man in charge of britains army has made a frankly astonishing admission that if we were ever to get into a conventional war with russia wed struggle. The following is an incomplete list of armed conflicts and wars fought by russia, by russian people, from antiquity to the present day. The best foreign policy stories of 2018 on defense and security. Robert farley, a frequent contributor to the national interest, is author of the battleship book.
European union eu vs russia 2017 who would win army. Everywhere else, long way from russian border usa has more chances but no. It also includes wars fought outside russia by russian military. Sep 01, 2003 widespread media interest into the chechen conflict reflects an ongoing concern about the evolution of federal russia. As far as who would win in a war, this is definetly no contest. According to research organization rand, should a major conflict arise in russia. Russia has had had a lot of sanctions on them by the eu, and their economy is shrinking. England, france, west germany all of these countries had large roles to play. China loses power, russia wont exist the worlds superpowers will be thrown into chaos and the war on is will end. Stalingrad was covered well as it was the emotional turning point of the war for russia i. And as the russians began to recapture their lands, the germans also used a scorchedearth policy.
The new yasen submarines can be decisive far away are the times of the cold war, in which both russia and the united states looked each other in the eye when controlling the seas of the entire planet. To the russians, it could easily have looked like a genuine preparation for a nuclear strike, the documents revealed. In the event of a war with russia, prepositioned stockpiles would supply a force of 15,000 for. If america and russia went to war who would most likely win. Our 9 year old loves this series about putting various animals against one another in battle. Who would win in a hypothetical war between russia and the eu. A vice admiral of the navy analyzes the current operation of both fleets. An urgent warning from senior military command shirreff, general sir richard on. He has written several books, including agents of innovation and a military history of japan. The sheer numbers of troops would be a problem but russia would have 4000 miles to bomb them along the way. Ultimately as a work of fiction 2017 war with russia misses the bar set by others, better storytellers like tom clancy or august cole and p. The european union spends only one third as much as the united states does for. We are talking only about a conventional war fought at russias borders.
Insofar as one can glean lessons from their military writings, and courtesy of my own conversations with russian officers, both serving and. Russia relations the united states and russia have been in contact since the u. Once the soviet union had declared war, stalin could no longer act as a. But yeah, that book is basically this scenario in the midtolate 80s as i recall. Heres who would win if russia, china, and america went to. In the mid1990s, a prominent component of russian foreign policy was recovery of military and economic influence in as many cis nations as possible. China would bring russia down, they definetly have some good tactics though. Chilling world war iii wargames show us forces crushed by russia and china.
The united states vastly outnumbers the russian federations strength in aircraft and ground forces. Russia wont win a fight with, say, finland, the eu, and america. If a war broke out between the united states and china, the clash between two of the worlds most powerful militaries would be horrific. According to roberts, following world war ii, the soviet union was much less enthusiastic about the cold war than its recent allies, the usa and great britain. War with russia, which is at once a literary disaster, a pacy technothriller and a clarion call to the west. Germany would beat france i dont see france ever being able to win a war tbh. The usa public will not tolerate high casualties so russia would most likely win a non nuclear war. A bit dated as it uses 1980scold war hardware and tactics as reference, but still an amazing book.
Now, the countries military spending draws upon a smaller percentage of its national expenditure. What he unleashed that day became would become one of the most vicious and deadly human endeavors in history. The united states and great britain were already convening war crimes trials in europe. What would happen if britain went to war with russia. No one is expecting war between russia and ukraine. If any other big players get involved, things change dramatically. Check out the infographics shows delightfully frightening breakdown of who would win if russia and the. Russia united kingdom relations, also anglorussian relations, involve the bilateral relationship between russia and great britain. Soviet union could have won wwii alone historian rt. By the way if it werent for russia putting up such a long fight hitler would have defeated the. Im assuming that the questioner means that russia is on the attack and britain on the defence. In august 1914 he was operations officer in east prussia, and was primarily his plans which were used to win the battle of tannenberg. China spends almost 3 times more on military compared to russia, but is its army really stronger.
1529 1448 594 321 629 1294 1590 329 971 674 1428 513 1504 1459 257 47 1208 1372 1334 1472 422 1279 535 1460 1182 1407 259 175 757 926 1003 789